35 Comments
User's avatar
ANTOINETTE PIETROPINTO's avatar

A beautiful eulogy to an admirable Justice!

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Jessie Roper's avatar

Thank you for this brief bio. What a shame that our current situation is so foreign to who he was!

Expand full comment
Jane Stolowich's avatar

This is a wonderful tribute to Justice Souter. I came to understand the Supreme Court better because of his writings and general demeanor.

Expand full comment
Phil Johnson's avatar

As a now-retired criminal defense lawyer, it was hard to appreciate the requirement for reflection one needs in this profession. For too long and too often, jurists and lawyers alike are caught up in the daily press of cases to think about the higher aspects of their clients' and litigants' lives and that we all serve an almighty and eternal purpose of some kind. This life is not all there is to reality, because I know now that I am closer to the end than the beginning.

Expand full comment
SPW's avatar

I look at this court and wonder, did those days of Justice Souter ever exist? If so then the last 25 years have dissolved in a blur. That’s how much oxygen has been sucked out of the Supreme Court since his retirement.

Expand full comment
Kev Ward's avatar

This is a beautifully written tribute! Sauter would (modestly) approve!

Expand full comment
Richard Goutal's avatar

Nicely done, Harry! It makes my heart ache for what COULD be, if only.

Expand full comment
Jana Nestlerode's avatar

Thank you for this. I have always admired Justice Souter.

Expand full comment
Jane Petty's avatar

What a wonderful history of a man who I knew the least of and he was a judge to beat all judges on our Supreme Court except the three women who bring a bit of our constitution clearly in focus not partisan !

Expand full comment
Jon Margolis's avatar

Thank you. Your reference to Learned Hand, who served on the Court of Appeals with his cousin, Augustus, reminds me that one of my professors said that in the Second Circuit the motto was, “Quote Learned, but follow Gus.” Would Justice Souter have approved? I’d like to think so.

Expand full comment
Deborah Engle's avatar

I now what to learn more about Justice Souter and his rulings/writings

Expand full comment
Dawn's avatar

Thanks for this profile of Souter. Judicial modesty and humility are virtues in short supply in today's SCOTUS.

Expand full comment
Phyllis Hedges's avatar

Wonderfully written, insightful. Makes me wince that we have lost his approach to justice and society on the Supreme Court.

Expand full comment
George's avatar

Thank you.

Expand full comment
Patricia Adamo's avatar

That was a man I could fall in love with marry! A shame we have Thomas and Alito instead! 😒

Expand full comment
Lynette Mason's avatar

Thank you for this beautiful tribute. Those were the days.

Expand full comment
Jason Christian's avatar

My father, who served on the California Court of Appeal, considered the defense of the legitimacy of the Courts among his highest obligations, overriding his own political positions.

Justice Souter was a great hero for that proposition.

Thank you for the remembrance. Honor to the Courts and their Officers!

Expand full comment